Which is better: Cash Back or Points?

It depends on your goals. Cash Back offers guaranteed value and simplicity (usually 1.5% to 2% return). Points offer higher potential value (often 3% to 10% return) if you redeem them for business class flights, but requires more effort and flexibility.

Most bank points (Chase, Amex, Citi, Capital One) do not expire as long as your account is open. However, airline miles and hotel points often expire after 18-24 months of inactivity.

Home
/
Credit Card Rewards
/
Cash Back vs Points

Cash Back vs. Points Calculator

Compare the net value of using a Cash Back card vs. a Points Earning card.

Purchase Amount ($)

Option A: Cash Back Card

Cash Back Rate (%)

Option B: Points Card

Points Multiplier (Points/$1)

Point Valuation (Cents/Point) Estimate what 1 point is worth.

Comparison Result

Cash Back Value

$0.00

Guaranteed Return

Points Value

$0.00

Estimated Return

Winner: --

How This Tool Works

The "Cash vs. Points" debate comes down to one question: Do you want simplicity or maximum value?

Formula: (Points * Value Per Point) vs. (Spend * Cash Back Rate).
Logic: We compare the guaranteed return of cash back against the potential higher value of points.
Assumptions: Cash is always worth 1 cent. Points vary from 0.5 to 2.0+ cents depending on redemption.

How to Use (Steps)

Enter Purchase Amount: (e.g., $1,000).
Set Cash Back Rate: (e.g., 2% for a standard card).
Set Points Multiplier: (e.g., 3x points on travel).
Compare: See which method puts more value in your pocket.

Example Calculation

Scenario: Spending $1,000 on a flight.

• Option A (2% Cash): $1,000 * 2% = $20.00.
• Option B (3x Points @ 1.5cpp): 3,000 Points * $0.015 = $45.00.
• Verdict: Points win by $25.00 (125% more value).

Why This Tool Is Accurate

Most people undervalue points. This tool allows you to input a custom "Cents Per Point" (CPP) value, showing the true leverage of transferable currencies.

Limitations & Disclaimer

Points fluctuate in value. Availability for high-value flights is limited. Disclaimer: Cash is liquid; points are not. Don't hoard points for too long.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there a risk to hoarding points?

Yes. Points devalue over time. Airlines and hotels constantly increase the cost of award redemptions. "Earn and burn" (using points as you earn them) is the best strategy. Cash, on the other hand, can be invested.

Can I convert cash back to points?

Sometimes. Cards like the Chase Freedom Flex earn "cash back" in the form of Ultimate Rewards points. If you also hold a premium card (like the Sapphire Preferred), you can combine them and transfer to airlines. Without a premium card, they are just cash.

When does cash back beat points?

If you redeem points for gift cards, merchandise, or "pay with points" at checkout (Amazon), you often get 0.6 to 0.8 cents per point value. In this case, a simple 2% cash back card would have earned you significantly more money.